The Best Music Notation Software: MuseScore, Sibelius, and Dorico Compared

Music notation software has come a long way, giving composers and musicians powerful tools to bring their compositions to life digitally. In this article, I’ll take a look at three of the most popular and robust music notation applications: MuseScore, Sibelius, and Dorico. Each has its own strengths, weaknesses, and unique features, so let’s dive in and compare them.

---

1. MuseScore

MuseScore is widely praised as the go-to free music notation software. It’s open-source, which makes it incredibly accessible, but don’t let the free price tag fool you—MuseScore is highly capable and offers many of the same features found in premium applications.

Pros:

• Free: The biggest advantage of MuseScore is that it’s completely free with no subscription or upfront costs.
• Community-driven: With its open-source nature, it has a large community that contributes to its development, offering regular updates and plugins.
• User-friendly: Even beginners can find their way around MuseScore quite easily, thanks to its intuitive design.
• Extensive online library: Users can download or share their scores with the community via MuseScore’s website. To get full access you will need a MuseScore Pro account.
• Cross-platform: Available on Windows, macOS, and Linux.

Cons:

• Not as advanced: While MuseScore has many useful features, it lacks some of the high-end features found in professional tools like Sibelius or Dorico.
• Basic playback: Its playback feature isn’t as refined as those in other applications. The sounds are decent, but not industry-leading. You can upgrade to better sounds (Muse Sounds) but most are a paid upgrade.
• Limited support for advanced workflows: If you’re dealing with complex, large-scale compositions, you might find MuseScore’s functionality a bit limiting.

---

2. Sibelius

Sibelius is a leading commercial music notation software known for its professional-grade features. It’s been a favorite among professionals and educators for years. Sibelius offers a tiered pricing model, ranging from a free version (Sibelius First) to the full-featured Sibelius Ultimate.

Pros:

• Professional-grade: Sibelius Ultimate is packed with advanced features for complex compositions, orchestration, and film scoring.
• Intelligent score layout: Sibelius can automatically adjust and optimize your score layout, making it quick and efficient.
• Playback quality: Sibelius’ playback is more refined than MuseScore, featuring a wide range of high-quality instrument sounds.
• Educational tools: Offers tools like the ability to input with a MIDI keyboard and use real-time notation input.

Cons:

• Price: The free version, Sibelius First, is limited in features, while Sibelius Ultimate comes with a hefty subscription fee.
• Steep learning curve: While it’s highly capable, it can take a while to master all of Sibelius’ advanced features.
• Subscription model: Some users dislike the reliance on a subscription model, as opposed to a one-time purchase.

---

3. Dorico

Dorico, developed by Steinberg, is relatively new to the music notation scene but has quickly gained a reputation for its forward-thinking design and capabilities. Dorico excels in streamlining workflows and is especially favored by composers who need flexibility and professional-quality output.

Pros:

• Advanced workflow: Dorico’s intuitive design and features cater to advanced composers and orchestrators.
• Engraving quality: Dorico is widely regarded as having the best engraving engine, ensuring beautifully laid-out scores that require minimal manual adjustments.
• Flexible notation: Dorico allows for unparalleled flexibility, handling complex time signatures, note groupings, and custom layouts with ease.
• Playback: Dorico integrates with Steinberg’s HALion sound library, providing excellent playback quality.

Cons:

• Price: Dorico is a premium product, and its pricing reflects that. While there is a free version, Dorico SE, it’s quite limited.
• Steep learning curve: Like Sibelius, Dorico is packed with advanced features, meaning it requires a significant investment of time to master.
• Heavier system requirements: Dorico’s advanced features can be more demanding on your system compared to MuseScore or even Sibelius.

---

Which One Should You Choose?

The best music notation software for you largely depends on your needs and budget.

• MuseScore is an excellent choice if you’re just starting out or need a robust tool without spending any money. It’s perfect for students, hobbyists, or anyone looking for something easy to use.
• Sibelius is ideal for professionals or advanced musicians who need powerful features and top-quality playback. It’s also great for educators due to its educational tools and integration with MIDI keyboards.
• Dorico is the best option for composers who need maximum flexibility and professional-quality engraving. If you’re working on complex compositions, Dorico’s superior layout and workflow options make it the most future-proof choice.